
Shop rules
These hang over the bench. Each big rule has a bench note behind it, with the panels and the sources. The small ones ride along.
A rule is just a mistake somebody already made for you. Take the gift.
The big nine

Rule No. 1
Never force a stuck cartridge.
It is stuck for a reason. Loosen it, or let a puller do the pulling.

Rule No. 2
Two wrenches, then count the turns.
Hand tight, then the maker's number: 3/4 turn by BrassCraft's sheet, about 1/2 turn after the sleeve grabs by Oatey's. The sheet in your box wins.

Rule No. 3
Grease the O-rings.
Silicone grease, a small dab. Nothing with petroleum in it, ever.

Rule No. 4
Read the washer, then read the seat.
A faucet that keeps eating washers has a damaged seat. Your fingernail finds it. A seat wrench or a seat dresser fixes it.

Rule No. 5
Count the turns on your main, and never force it.
The count says the gate made its whole trip. Stiff? Ease the packing nut a quarter to half turn. Force an old one and the stem unscrews from the gate.

Rule No. 6
Sleeve the cold pipes before the freeze.
Foam slows the cold down and buys you time. It does not make heat.

Rule No. 7
Cut square, deburr, mark the depth.
A push fitting holds only what you give it: a square, clean pipe end pushed all the way home.

Rule No. 8
Hand tight means hand tight.
The plastic nuts on a toilet get fingers, by Fluidmaster's and Korky's sheets, and TOTO says hand tight on the supply nut. Fluidmaster says a cranked one can break and cause a flood.

Rule No. 9
No ratchet cutter on cold CPVC.
Below 50 degrees F, Wavin says never use one. Lubrizol says it squeezes the pipe, and cold CPVC can crack. Cut with a wheel cutter made for plastic or a fine tooth saw, and cut at least two inches past any crack.
The small ones
Each of these comes out of one of the notes above. The number says which.
- Twist it before you pull it.Sediment and mineral hold a stuck cartridge. A quarter turn each way breaks it loose, then it pulls. Yank first and the stem can come out alone and leave the shell in the valve. That one is a plumber's. From note No. 1
- Snug, then stop.On a compression stop that is hand tight, then 3/4 turn by BrassCraft's sheet or about 1/2 turn after the sleeve grabs by Oatey's. The sheet in your box wins. The turn squeezes the sleeve onto the tube, and the sleeve is the seal. Past it, BrassCraft says the stop can crack and fail over time. Still weeping at the number? A nudge, just enough to stop it. Still weeping after that? Water off, take it apart, look at the sleeve. Stub-out too short to cut back to clean, round tube? That one's a plumber's. From note No. 2
- Hand tight means hand tight.The plastic lock nut and the plastic coupling nut on a toilet get fingers only, by Fluidmaster's and Korky's sheets, and TOTO says hand tight on the supply nut; the metal nut on the stop gets 1/2 turn past hand tight by Fluidmaster's Click Seal sheet, and the sheet with your connector wins. Fluidmaster says an overtightened lock nut or coupling nut can break and cause a flood. Leak at the tank once the water is on? Turn the coupling nut just enough to stop it, and no more. Crack in the tank or bowl? Water off at the stop; that one's a plumber's. From note No. 8
- No tape on a compression nut.The sleeve seals metal to metal, not the threads, and Oatey says tape there can cause leaks. BrassCraft says a drop of general purpose oil makes the turn easier. Leaking at the number with clean threads? Take it apart and look at the sleeve. From note No. 2
- Nothing with petroleum on rubber.Silicone-based grease only. Moen also rules out plumber's grade faucet grease and silicone sprays, so a tub that says plumber's grease is not automatically safe. Petroleum can react with the seals and make the handle stiffer. Still leaking with new rings? It is the cartridge or the valve, not the grease. From note No. 3
- Read the seat with your fingernail.A scratch that catches your nail wears a new washer out sooner than a smooth seat would. A washer that keeps leaking can cut the seat, so the drip makes it worse. Too deep to dress smooth? New seat or new faucet. From note No. 4
- Square or six-sided hole, it comes out.Seat wrench, counterclockwise; the new one goes in clockwise. A plain round hole with no slots stays put and gets dressed in place. Seat will not turn with the wrench? Stop there. From note No. 4
- Stuck gate valve? Ease the packing nut first.A quarter to a half turn off, Crane says, then work the valve and snug the nut back. Still won't move? Stop. The stem is screwed into the gate, and if crud has the gate jammed, cranking the wheel only unscrews the stem. Wheel turns, no water: a dropped gate, and a new valve. From note No. 5
- Gate valve main? Write the turn count on its tag.Close it slow and count, open to closed, the way water systems check their own valves. The count says the gate made its whole trip. Next time it comes up short or grinds, it goes on the repair list, not on a cheater bar. Then show the house where it is. From note No. 5
- Gate valve: all the way open, then back a quarter turn.Parked hard against the top, a gate valve can seize there and fight you the day you need to close it. The Environmental Finance Center Network tells water systems to back theirs off about a quarter turn for that, and Crane says keep the stem off the backseat so the packing does the sealing. Never on a lever: a quarter back on a ball valve shuts it. Already stuck at full open? Repair list, not a cheater bar. From note No. 5
- Measure the pipe, then buy the foam.Pipe is sold by its inside size and the foam has to fit the outside. Armacell's chart: a 5/8 inch sleeve on 1/2 inch copper, PEX or CPVC, and 7/8 on 3/4 inch. Iron pipe runs bigger. Put a 1/2 inch sleeve on 1/2 inch copper and it will not close around the pipe. Pipe already frozen or split? Water off at the main first; foam fixes neither. From note No. 6
- Insulation stays clear of the flue.On a gas water heater, six inches back from the flue and the draft diverter, and none on the relief valve; that is the Department of Energy's checklist. Armacell rates its Tubolit foam for lines up to 180 degrees F. Look where the pipes leave the top of the heater: that is where foam ends up touching the draft hood. No foam on the flue, ever. From note No. 6
- No ratchet cutter on cold CPVC.Below 50 degrees F, Wavin says never use a ratchet cutter on CPVC. Lubrizol says it squeezes the pipe, and cold CPVC can crack. Use a wheel cutter made for plastic or a fine tooth saw in a miter box, check the end after every cut, and cut at least two inches past any crack. Crack runs into a wall you cannot open? That one is a plumber's. From note No. 9
The tips library
The shop rules say what. The tips say how much, in what order and how you can tell, with the source under every one.
Valves that have to work
Back a stuck gate valve's packing nut off 1/4 to 1/2 turn before you work it, why an old gate drops, and which way a globe valve goes in.
5 tips
Sillcocks done right
Pitch a frost-free down toward the outside, buy it at least 2 inches longer than the wall is thick, and give an anti-siphon one 12 hours of continuous pressure, tops.
6 tips
Threads and what goes on them
Tape clockwise with the first thread bare, sealant on the male thread only, and finger tight plus one or two turns on plastic female threads.
5 tips
Sweat it right
A gap of 0.004 to 0.006 inch, the flame on the tube before the cup, and a length of wire about the size of the pipe.
9 tips
PEX by the numbers
Crimp rings 1/8 to 1/4 inch back from the end, a 1/8 turn between expansions, and no bend tighter than 6 times the tube's actual outside diameter.
9 tips
Glue joints
A dry fit that binds 1/3 to 2/3 of the way in, primer until the plastic goes soft, then a quarter turn and a hold.
8 tips
Drains, traps and cast iron
The washer's tapered side toward the threaded fitting, score, turn and snap on cast iron, and 60 inch-pounds on a no-hub band.
9 tips
Setting a toilet
The flange on top of the finished floor, tank nuts snugged side to side until it sits level and stops rocking, and 1/2 inch of slack in the flapper chain.
9 tips
Caulk that holds
Every bit of the old bead out, backer rod 1/8 inch bigger than the joint, and silicone where it's wet, latex where it's painted.
6 tips
Where the rules come from
He says them. He does not make them up. Every rule here stands on the sources listed at the bottom of its bench note: the makers' own instruction sheets first, then water utilities and the long-standing trade publishers.

