The Old Tradesman

Bench note No. 2

Two Wrenches, Then Count the Turns

Compression joints by the numbers: the backup wrench, how far past hand tight, what goes on the threads, and why a weep gets a nudge, never a crank.

  1. The Old Tradesman holds up two adjustable wrenches, one in each hand

    Panel 1. The Old Tradesman says: Compression nut on a stop: hand tight, then the wrench, and count. BrassCraft's sheet says 3/4 turn on a copper inlet. Oatey's says about 1/2 turn after the sleeve grabs the tube. The sheet in your box wins.

  2. Close up of two hands with two adjustable wrenches on a brass shutoff valve: one wrench holds the valve body, the other turns the compression nut on the supply tube

    Panel 2. The Old Tradesman says: One wrench holds the valve body. The other turns the nut. Count flats, not feel: six to a nut, so 1/2 turn is three flats and 3/4 turn is four and a half. That turn squeezes the sleeve onto the tube. The sleeve is the seal.

  3. The Old Tradesman squeezes one drop of oil from a small oil can onto the threads of a brass stop valve, a roll of thread tape pushed to the far end of the bench

    Panel 3. The Old Tradesman says: No tape on a compression nut. Oatey says these joints seal metal to metal, and tape there can cause leaks. BrassCraft says no tape, putty or gasket stuff, and a drop of oil makes tightening easier.

  4. The Old Tradesman lines up a thin supply riser tube over the outlet of a brass stop valve, a compression nut and sleeve on the tube and a tubing cutter on the bench

    Panel 4. The Old Tradesman says: Outlet side: cut the riser so it bottoms out in the stop, seated and square. Then BrassCraft's numbers: copper gets 1 to 1-1/4 turns past hand tight, PEX gets 1-1/2 to 2. Riser in crooked? Fix the riser. Turns won't.

  5. The Old Tradesman kneels beside a toilet and turns the plastic nut of a braided supply line by hand under the tank, his adjustable wrench left on the floor

    Panel 5. The Old Tradesman says: Braided line to a toilet: the metal nut on the stop gets 1/2 turn past hand tight, per Fluidmaster's sheet. The plastic nut on the fill valve gets fingers only. American Standard says a cranked coupling nut can break and flood the room.

  6. The Old Tradesman squints at a brass compression nut on a short piece of copper pipe, an adjustable wrench and a brass compression tee on the bench

    Panel 6. The Old Tradesman says: Weeping at the number? Give it a nudge, just enough to stop it. Never a crank: BrassCraft says overtightening can crack the stop. Still weeping? Water off, take it apart, look at the sleeve and the tube.

The note

My rule: if one wrench is turning a nut, another wrench is holding what that nut threads onto. Family Handyman, writing about the packing nut on a shutoff, says the pressure you put on a nut to turn it can cause leaks in other parts of the valve or in the pipe connections, and says to use two wrenches, one to hold the valve and one to turn the nut. Water off and the pressure let out before any of it.

A compression joint seals at the sleeve, the brass ring the nut squeezes onto the tube. Oatey says these fittings seal metal to metal. The turn past hand tight does the squeezing, so the turn is the whole job. BrassCraft’s stop sheet says hand tighten as far as it goes, then 3/4 turn with a wrench on a copper or PEX inlet. Oatey’s sheet says the nut is normally leak tight after an extra 1/2 turn once the sleeve compresses onto the tube. Family Handyman says 1/2 to 3/4 turn and to follow the maker’s instructions. Two makers, two numbers, and the sheet in your box wins. A hex nut has six flats, so 1/2 turn is three flats and 3/4 turn is four and a half. Count them.

Past the number is where the trouble starts. BrassCraft says overtightening can make the stop crack and fail over time, and its compression fitting sheet says it can lead to leaking long after installation. This Old House says it can deform the ferrule and make the leak worse.

No tape on those threads, ever. BrassCraft says no putty, gasket material or thread seal tape, and that a drop of general purpose oil makes tightening easier. Oatey says no pipe joint compound or thread sealant tape on its compression threads, and its tape guide says tape on a compression fitting can cause leaks. BrassCraft does allow a thin coat of sealant on the male threads only, kept off the sleeve, and warns that too much can make the joint fail. Oatey allows none on the threads. Family Handyman puts a very light coat of pipe dope on the sleeve; BrassCraft’s sheet says keep sealant off it. Your sheet decides.

The outlet has its own numbers. BrassCraft says cut the riser so it bottoms out in the stop and stays seated and square, then tighten 1 to 1-1/4 turns past hand tight on copper and 1-1/2 to 2 turns on PEX. On PEX bigger than 3/8 inch OD it calls for the brass sleeve with a stainless steel tube insert; 3/8 inch and smaller takes the plastic sleeve. Stub-out and riser both have to be square, round and free of burrs.

A braided connector comes with its own washers, and BrassCraft’s sheet says no thread sealant on it. On a toilet, Fluidmaster’s connector sheet says the metal nut on the shutoff valve gets 1/2 turn past hand tight and the plastic nut on the fill valve shank is hand tightened. BrassCraft says a connector’s wing nut on a toilet ballcock is hand tight only, and a metal nut there gets hand tight, then 1/4 turn more. American Standard warns that overtightening the lock nut or coupling nut can cause breakage and flooding, and Fluidmaster’s fill valve sheet says overtightened nuts can crack the tank or bowl.

If it weeps at the number, it gets a nudge, not a crank. BrassCraft’s fitting sheet says if a leak is present, tighten the appropriate nut; Fluidmaster’s connector sheet says just enough for a leak-free joint. Still weeping after that? Water off, take it apart and look. Family Handyman says that if the old sleeve left marks on the tube, you set the new sleeve slightly forward of them. A tube that is not square, round and clean gets cut back to good tube, and the joint gets made again.

One more: a pipe wrench stays on pipe. Ridgid’s pipe wrench sheet says not to use one on hard, square, hexagonal or other non-round material: it may slip, or its teeth may chip.

References

  1. BrassCraft, Water Supply Stops Installation Instructions
  2. BrassCraft, Compression Fittings Installation Instructions (retailer-hosted copy)
  3. Oatey, Quarter Turn Valve Instruction Guide
  4. Oatey, How to Use Plumber's Tape
  5. Family Handyman, Leaky Shut-Off Valve? Here's How to Fix It
  6. Family Handyman, How to Replace a Shutoff Valve
  7. This Old House, Adding Sink Shutoff Valves: A DIY Guide
  8. Fluidmaster, Click Seal Toilet Connector Installation Instructions (retailer-hosted copy)
  9. Fluidmaster, 400A Fill Valve Installation Instructions (distributor-hosted copy)
  10. American Standard, Toilet Installation Instructions (distributor-hosted copy)
  11. Ridgid, Pipe Wrench Use Guide (distributor-hosted copy)

The technique in this note comes from these sources. He is the voice. They are the authority. The panels are cartoons, not photographs.