Bench note No. 4

Read the Old Part Before You Throw It Out
The old washer tells you why it dripped. The seat it closed on tells you whether a new one will last. How to read both, and what to do about a bad seat.

Panel 1. The Old Tradesman says: Hold it. A faucet that keeps eating washers does not have a washer problem. It has a damaged seat. So before this stem hits the bin, read the washer on it. Then go read the seat it closed on.

Panel 2. The Old Tradesman says: Squeezed flat or a groove worn in it? That washer is done. The new one matches it: same size, same type. Measure across it. A worn one can hide whether it was flat or coned, so pick the new one by the recess at the bottom of the stem: it has to sit down in there. Flipping an old flat one is a stopgap.

Panel 3. The Old Tradesman says: That little screw holding the washer should be brass, and brass is soft. Small brass screws and stems twist off easy, worse with a big tool. Then they are junk. A steel one rusts: clear the slot before you turn it. Going back in, tight enough that it won't back out. No tighter.

Panel 4. The Old Tradesman says: Now the seat. Stem out, drag a fingernail across it. A scratch or a groove that catches your nail will wear the new washer out early. Smooth, and the washer lasts. Can't feel it? Get somebody to look down the hole with a light.

Panel 5. The Old Tradesman says: Scored? Look down the hole with a light. A square or six-sided hole, or screwdriver slots, means the seat comes out: seat wrench, counterclockwise. The new one goes in clockwise with a little pipe joint compound or RTV on its threads. A plain round hole with no slots is not coming out. That one gets dressed.

Panel 6. The Old Tradesman says: A seat that stays in gets dressed. The cutter has to fit the seat: 1/4, 3/8 or 1/2 inch on a common kit. Set the tool in with the packing nut and turn until the seat is smooth. The cone keeps the cut level. Blow out the chips, then run your nail over it again. Still catches? New seat, or new faucet.
The note
Shut the water off and open the faucet before a stem comes out. Then read what you took out, starting at the bottom with the washer. Danco and Millard Lumber say the same thing: a seat washer that is squeezed flat, or has a groove worn in it, gets replaced. The new one should be the same size and type, and the Michigan State University Extension bulletin says to measure the diameter. VisionAware warns that a badly worn washer can hide whether it was flat or slightly cone shaped, and the new one has to fit into the recess at the bottom of the stem. Reversing the old washer, that Extension bulletin says, is a temporary fix, especially if it is a flat disc.
The washer is held on by a small screw, and it should be brass. Brass is soft. The old USDA bulletin on simple plumbing repairs says small brass screws and stems are easily twisted off, especially if a large tool is used. If someone put in a screw that is not brass, VisionAware says the head may be corroded, and the rust has to come out of the slot before it will turn. Going back in, tighten it so it does not come loose, but not so tight that it breaks. Millard Lumber says a damaged brass screw gets replaced with a new brass screw.
Now the part most people skip: the seat the washer closes on. Millard Lumber puts it plainly. Any faucet that needs frequent washer replacement has a damaged seat. The old USDA bulletin gives the reason it gets that way: a worn washer leaking over the seat, with grit lodged there, often cuts, nicks and grooves it, and it happens more often on the hot side. So a drip left alone wrecks the seat, not just the washer. With the stem out, drag a fingernail across the seat. VisionAware says you can sometimes inspect it that way, and that scratches or grooves will wear a new washer down sooner than a smooth seat would. If your nail cannot tell you, have someone look down into the faucet with a light. The Extension bulletin’s check is the same: be sure the seat is not scored.
Before you reach for a tool, find out what kind of seat it is. Millard Lumber says to check with a flashlight: a seat with a square or hexagonal hole through its center, or slots for a screwdriver, is replaceable. A seat with only a plain round hole and no slots is not. A replaceable seat comes out with a seat wrench turned counterclockwise and goes in clockwise, and Danco’s instructions say the same. Millard adds a little silicone rubber sealant (RTV) or pipe joint compound around the threads of the new seat before it goes in. Danco’s cure for a flattened or grooved washer is a new washer and a new seat together.
A seat that is part of the faucet body gets dressed where it sits. This Old House says to grind a pitted seat smooth with a valve-seat dresser. BrassCraft’s page for its reseating tool lists cutters for 1/4, 3/8 and 1/2 inch seats and a centering cone that helps keep the cut level, and the old USDA bulletin says a seat dresser saves buying new faucets. Millard Lumber’s steps: set the tool in the faucet with the packing nut, rotate it until the seat is smooth, and blow out the chips. Then run your fingernail over it again before the stem goes back. If the grooves are too deep, VisionAware says, the seat or the whole faucet gets replaced.
If the stem itself is the worn part and you need to match it, that is a parts question, not a bench note. Our sister site Stems & Cartridges keeps an index for matching a stem by its numbers.
References
- Millard Lumber, How To: Faucet and Valve Repair
- APH VisionAware, Faucet Washer Replacement
- Michigan State University Extension, Get Rid of the Drip in Your House, Bulletin E-811 (hosted by Bay County, Michigan)
- Danco, How to Repair a Leaky Two-Handle Faucet
- Danco, Faucet Remodeling Kit instructions (seat wrench steps)
- BrassCraft, Long Stem Faucet Reseating Tool
- This Old House, Fixing a Leaky Faucet
- USDA Farmers' Bulletin 1460, Simple Plumbing Repairs in the Home (Project Gutenberg)
The technique in this note comes from these sources. He is the voice. They are the authority. The panels are cartoons, not photographs.
